Research Progress and Review on the Institutional Repository Evaluation

  • Zhang Yaqi ,
  • Sheng Xiaoping
Expand
  • School of Economic and Management, South China Normal University, Guangzhou 510006

Received date: 2015-04-01

  Revised date: 2015-04-20

  Online published: 2015-05-05

Abstract

[Purpose/significance] Institutional repository evaluation is of great significance. Through the summary and analysis of the practices on institutional repository evaluation at home and abroad, this paper reveals research progress on institutional repository evaluation and provides direction for the further research.[Method/process] This paper summarizes research progress on institutional repository evaluation from three aspects of evaluation contents, evaluation index, evaluation methods based on literature analysis. Evaluation contents of institutional repository consist of system software, digital resource management, attitude of institutional members, practice and development, influencing factors and performance evaluation. Evaluation indexes of institutional repository consist of eight types. Evaluation methods of institutional repositories consist of methods of balanced scorecard, focus group interview and link analysis.[Result/conclusion] The practices on institutional repository evaluation have made significant progress so far, however it still needs to improve.

Cite this article

Zhang Yaqi , Sheng Xiaoping . Research Progress and Review on the Institutional Repository Evaluation[J]. Library and Information Service, 2015 , 59(9) : 127 -135 . DOI: 10.13266/j.issn.0252-3116.2015.09.018

References

[1] Bjrk B C, Laakso M, Welling P, et al. Anatomy of green open access[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,2014,65(2):237-250.
[2] 袁顺波,华薇娜,马学良.国内外机构库评价研究现状述评[J].图书情报工作,2011,55(11):5-8.
[3] 孙坦,陶俊.2002-2009年国外机构仓储评价研究述评[J].图书馆建设,2010(4):6-9.
[4] Open Society Institute. A guide to institutional repository software[R/OL].[2015-01-17].http://www.budapestopenaccessinitiative.org/pdf/OSI_Guide_to_IR_Software_v3.pdf.
[5] Bankier J G, Gleason K. Institutional repository software comparison[EB/OL].[2015-01-31].http://disde.minedu.gob.pe/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/2899/Institutional%20Repo sitory%20Software%20Comparison.pdf?sequence=1.
[6] Singh S K, Witt M, Dorothea S. A comparative analysis of institutional repository software[C/OL].[2015-02-26].http://www.or10.es/Resources/documentos/GSabstracts/AComparative AnalysisInstitutionalRepositorySoftware.pdf.
[7] Chan D L H, Kwok C S Y, Yip S K F. Changing roles of reference librarians: The case of the HKUST Institutional Repository[J].Reference Services Review,2005,33(3):268-282.
[8] Jones R D. DSpace and ETD-db comparative evaluation[R/OL].[2015-02-26].http://www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/1842/169/1/ComparativeEvaluation.pdf.
[9] Marill J L, Luczak E C. Evaluation of digital repository software at the National Library of Medicine[J/OL].[2015-02-26].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/may09/marill/05marill.html.
[10] 杨思洛,韩淑娟.机构知识库系统软件现状及评价方法[J].深图通讯,2007(4):26-29.
[11] Kim H H, Kim Y H. Usability study of digital institutional repositories[J].Electronic Library,2008,26(6):863-881.
[12] 洪梅,马建霞.开源机构库软件可用性评估方法的探讨[J].现代图书情报技术,2007(12):8-9.
[13] Xia Jinfeng, Sun Li. Factors to assess self-archiving in institutional repositories[J].Serials Review,2007,33(2):73-80.
[14] 郭清蓉.机构知识库自存储评价体系的构建[J].情报杂志,2009,28(7):75-76.
[15] 何燕.我国科研人员潜在自存储行为影响因素研究——以中国科学院科研人员为例[J].图书馆,2008(3):32-35.
[16] Xia Jinfeng. Assessment of self-archiving in institutional repositories: Across disciplines[J]. The Journal of Academic Librarianship,2007,33(6):647-654.
[17] Haddow G. Self-archiving to institutional repositories is improved by assisted and mandated deposit;disciplinary culture is not a factor[J].Evidence Based Library and Information Practice,2008,3(2):52-57.
[18] Xia Jinfeng. A comparison of subject and institutional repositories in self-archiving practice[J].The Journal of Academic Librarianship,2008,34(6):494-495.
[19] 李欣荣.科学的学术评价体系对机构典藏库自存储率的影响[J].图书馆理论与实践,2011(7):60-62.
[20] 林美玲,柯皓仁.作者与学术期刊对机构典藏态度之研究[D].新竹:"国立"交通大学,2009.
[21] 李欣荣.机构典藏库自存储率分析[J].情报科学,2011,29(1):55-57.
[22] Kim J. Motivations of faculty self-archiving in institutional repositories[J].The Journal of Academic Librarianship,2011,37(3):246-254.
[23] Markland M. Institutional repositories in the UK:What can the Google user find there?[J].Journal of Librarianship and Information Science,2006,38(4):221-228.
[24] Arlitsch K, O'Brien P S. Invisible institutional repositories:Addressing the low indexing ratios of IRs in Google Scholar[J].Library Hi Tech,2012,30(1):60-81.
[25] Ordua-Malea E, López-Cózar E D. The dark side of open access in Google and Google Scholar:The case of Latin-American repositories[J].Scientometrics,2015,102(1):829-846.
[26] Lee J, Burnett G, Baeg J H, et al. Availability and accessibility in an open access institutional repository:A case study[J/OL].[2015-03-28].http://diginole.lib.fsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1029&context=slis_faculty_publications.
[27] Chavez R, Crane G, Sauer A, et al. Services make the repository[J/OL].[2015-03-01]. https://journals.tdl.org/jodi/index.php/jodi/article/view/195/179.
[28] Kim J H. Motivating and impeding factors affecting faculty contribution to institutional repositories[J/OL].[2015-01-21].http//journals.tdl.org/jodi/article/view/193/177.
[29] Kyriaki-Manessi D, Koulouris A, Giannakopoulos G, et al. Exploratory research regarding faculty attitudes towards the Institutional Repository and self archiving[J].Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,2013,73:777-784.
[30] Oguz F, Assefa S. Faculty members' perceptions towards institutional repository at a medium-sized university: Application of a binary logistic regression model[J].Library Review,2014,63(3):198-199.
[31] Alemayehu M W. Researchers' attitude to using institutional repositories:A case study of the Oslo University Institutional Repository (DUO)[D].Oslo: University of Oslo, 2010.
[32] 袁顺波.我国科研人员对自存储的认知和参与现状分析[J].图书情报工作,2013,57(13):49-53, 60.
[33] 宋海艳,邵承瑾,顾立平,等.我国科研人员对机构知识库认知与使用的现状调查与分析[J].现代图书情报技术,2014,30(2):8-16.
[34] Abrizah A. The cautious faculty:Their awareness and attitudes towards institutional repositories[J].Malaysian Journal of Library & Information Science,2009,14(2):17-37.
[35] Cullen R, Chawner B. Institutional repositories:Assessing their value to the academic community[J].Performance Measurement and Metrics,2010,11(2):141-142.
[36] Dutta G, Paul D. Awareness on institutional repositories-related issues by Faculty of University of Calcutta[J].DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology,2014,34(4):293-297.
[37] Davis P M, Connolly M J L. Institutional repositories:Evaluating the reasons for non-use of Cornell University's installation of DSpace[J/OL].[2015-03-11].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/march07/davis/03davis.html.
[38] van Westrienen G, Lynch C A. Academic institutional repositories deployment status in 13 nations as of mid 2005[J/OL].[2015-01-18].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/september05/westrienen/09westrienen.html.
[39] 袁顺波.科研人员采纳自存储的影响因素研究[J].图书情报知识,2014,31(2):72-83.
[40] Lynch C A, Lippincott J K. Institutional repository deployment in the United States as of early 2005[J/OL].[2015-01-18].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/september05/lynch/09lynch.html.
[41] Markey K, Rieh S Y, Jean B S, et al. Census of institutional repositories in the United States[R/OL].[2015-03-04].http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Elizabeth_Yakel/publication/2372 43686_Census_of_Institutional_Repositories_in_the_United_States/links/004635294b1582f771000000.pdf.
[42] van Eijndhoven K, van der Graaf M. Inventory study into the present type and level of OAI compliant Digital Repository activities in the EU[R/OL].[2015-03-09].http://www.pleiade.nl/rapport/DRIVERInventoryStudy.pdf.
[43] Kennan M A, Kingsley D A. The state of the nation: A snapshot of Australian institutional repositories[J/OL].[2015-03-31].http://pear.accc.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/2282/2092.
[44] Melero R, Falgueras E A, García M F A, et al. The situation of open access institutional repositories in Spain: 2009 report[R/OL].[2015-03-26]. http://www.informationr.net/ir/14-4/paper415.html.
[45] Ezema I J. Local contents and the development of open access institutional repositories in Nigeria University libraries: Challenges, strategies and scholarly implications[J].Library Hi Tech,2013,31(2):323-340.
[46] 肖希明,唐义.国内外学术机构知识库的调查与分析[J].图书馆论坛,2010,30(6):41-45.
[47] 唐义,肖希明.港台学术机构知识库的调查与分析[J].图书馆论坛,2011,31(4):38-41.
[48] Zhao Yongchao, Yao Xiaoxia, Wei Chengfu. Academic institutional repositories in China: A survey of CALIS member libraries[J].Chinese Journal of Library and Information Science,2012,5(2):18-32.
[49] 姚晓霞,聂华,顾立平,等.我国教育科研机构知识库建设现状调查与分析[J].现代图书情报技术,2014(5):1-9.
[50] 金瑛.机构仓储存储行为影响因素研究述评[J].图书馆建设,2010(4):14-17.
[51] Weenink K, Waaijers L, van Godtsenhoven K. A DRIVER's guide to European repositories[M].Amsterdam:Amsterdam University Press,2008.
[52] 何燕,初景利,张冬荣.我国科研人员自存储态度调查——以中国科学院科研人员为例[J].图书情报工作,2008,52(5):121-124.
[53] McDowell C. Evaluating institutional repository deployment in American academe since early 2005:Repositories by the numbers, part 2[J/OL].[2015-03-01].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/september05/westrienen/09westrienen.html.
[54] Shearer M K. Institutional repositories:Towards the identification of critical success factors[J].Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science,2002(3):89-108.
[55] Blythe E, Chachra V. The value proposition in institutional repositories[J].Educause Review,2005,40(5):76-77.
[56] Lagzian F, Abrizah A, Wee M C. Critical success factors for institutional repositories implementation[J].The Electronic Library,2015,33(2):169-209.
[57] 韩珂,祝忠明.机构仓储可持续发展关键问题研究[J].图书情报工作,2008,52(5):99-101.
[58] Amos H, Ruthven T. Becoming the authoritative source:Taking repositories centre stage[C/OL].[2015-03-04].http://docs.lib.purdue.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1846&context=iatul.
[59] 马学良.机构库评价的关键问题研究[J].图书情报工作,2011,55(11):9-12.
[60] 闾燕,侯振兴,袁勤俭.开放存取机构库综合评价模型研究[J].现代情报,2013,33(11):20-24.
[61] Thomas G. Evaluting the impact of the institutional repository,or positioning innovation between a rock and a hard place[J].New Review of Information Networking,2007,13(2):133-146.
[62] Vernet A. Copyright management,education and support in institutional repositories[D].Aberystwyth:Aberystwyth University,2012.
[63] 杨美洁,翁淳光.国内机构知识库网站的可用性评价[J].中华医学图书情报杂志,2014,23(12):6-9.
[64] 丁敬达,朱梦月.高校机构知识库网络影响力评价研究——基于我国重点大学的实证分析[J].图书馆杂志,2014,33(7):13-23.
[65] 林爱群.机构知识库元数据的自动生成与评估研究[J].图书馆学研究,2009(7):21-23.
[66] 于丹阳.基于SERVQUAL的机构知识库服务质量评价模型构建[J].浙江高校图书情报工作, 2012(6):6-8.
[67] Carr L, Brody T. Size isn't everything:Sustainable repositories as evidenced by sustainable deposit profiles[J/OL].[2015-03-10].http://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2412800&orden=139539&info=link.
[68] Cassella M. Institutional repositories:An internal and external perspective on the value of IRs for researchers'communities[J].Liber Quarterly,2010,20(2):210-225.
[69] 陈铭,叶继元.基于"全评价"分析框架的开放存取仓储评价体系研究[J].图书馆论坛,2014,34(8):40-47.
[70] 张毅君.机构知识库质量评价指标研究[J].现代情报,2011,31(10):50-52.
[71] Kim Y H, Kim H H. Development and validation of evaluation indicators for a consortium of institutional repositories:A case study of dCollection[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2008,59(8):1282-1294.
[72] 刘海霞,陈文洁,胡德华,等.机构仓储可持续发展综合评价指标体系研究[J].中国图书馆学报,2014,40(2):67-77.
[73] 刘玉红,史艳芬.机构知识库成功创建和可持续发展的要素研究[J].图书馆杂志,2010,29(2):27-30.
[74] Ranking Web of Repositories.Methodology[EB/OL].[2015-01-18].http://repositories.webometrics.info/en/Methodology.
[75] Thibodeau K. If you build it,will it fly?Criteria for success in a digital repository[J/OL]. [2015-03-04].http://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=2359165&orden=132208&info =link.
[76] 郭清蓉,郭玉强.基于层次分析法的机构知识库评价模型[J].高校图书情报论坛,2013,12(1):11-13.
[77] Westell M. Institutional repositories:Proposed indicators of success[J].Library Hi Tech, 2006,24(2):211-226.
[78] 郭翊,吉萍.机构知识库评价体系的构建[J].图书馆学刊,2014(2):10-12.
[79] Zuccala A, Thelwall M, Oppenheim C, et al. Digital repository management practices, user needs and potential users: An integrated analysis: Report of joint information systems committee project[R].Wolverhampton:University of Wolverhampton,2006.
[80] Wells P. Institutional repositories: investigating user groups and comparative evaluation using link analysis[D].Bristol:University of the West of England,2009.
[81] Smith A G. Web based impact measures for institutional repositories[C/OL].[2015-03-31].http://researcharchive.vuw.ac.nz/xmlui/bitstream/handle/10063/2881/paper.pdf?sequence=2.
[82] 邱均平,张心源,董克.Altmetries指标在机构知识库中的应用研究[J].图书情报工作,2015,59(2):100-105.

Outlines

/